The Hogwarts Legacy Should Avoid This Controversial Subject from Harry Potter


There is a lot of source material in the Hogwarts Legacy that can be taken into account when deciding whether to include items. A certain iconography will still go well with the setting of the “Hogwarts Legacy” of the 1800s at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, while much is likely to remain for the modern era in terms of environmental design. For example, it would be interesting to see the potential addition of Polyjuice to the Hogwarts Legacy gameplay.

However, one item can be reserved for the original books and films, as it could potentially cause more controversy in the “Legacy of Hogwarts”. We are talking about the flywheel of time, which is notorious as one of the worst inclusions in the franchise. Interestingly, one of the few reasons this was ever difficult to understand was due to the author who decided to make changes that stifled them and eventually excluded them from the canon. For this and many other reasons, the “Legacy of Hogwarts” would do well to distance itself from the Flywheel of Time.

Time flywheels are designed more or less so as not to affect events

The author of “Harry Potter” decided to change the rules of some of his works after the fact, including the logic of the flywheels of time. The use of Hermione Granger’s time flywheel made sense within the parameters of Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, but extrapolated knowledge and the origin of the subject is not so appropriate for its appearance in a book or movie. The legacy of Hogwarts was no different.

The time flywheel, in fact, allows its user to go back a few hours in time by turning the hourglass attached to the necklace. In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione used this subject to double her studies with a much bigger workload, and later she and Harry used it to prevent Buckbeak’s death and save Sirius Black. The “time travel” implemented here actually consists of a causal loop running parallel to the same events that Hermione and Harry return to. Thus, Harry was able to escape from the crowd of dementors, because he had the first and only time when this event happened. The idea is that you cannot change the events in the past that affect the past.

Flywheels of Time Can make the legacy of Hogwarts More Complicated than Necessary

Fans often ask why the time flywheels were not used in advance to prevent any dangers from Harry Potter’s past. It seems that the flywheels of time do not work like that, or work, but unintentionally. Someone who is dead cannot be saved from death by returning to the past, and if someone were to be executed by returning to the past through the flywheel of time, this would already have happened in the events of the causal loop. For example, if the “Legacy of Hogwarts” included a time flywheel, players would already have to accomplish any feat they accomplished in their time travel.

The flywheels of time, in fact, offer a second perspective of the same event happening simultaneously. So, while the flywheels of time may not make any plot holes due to the lack of changes that players could have made in the past, they will make certain sequences more complicated than necessary. Plot holes would be only one paradoxical choice, especially since the rules for their use are hanging in the air and restrictive.

WB Games Avalanche would have to take into account every detail in Hogwarts Legacy to reproduce any hour that players would like to return to, for example, with repetitive character dialogues and movements. However, using a magic item in the Hogwarts Legacy could lead to a return to the previous hour of the day, when players could attend more classes, as Hermione did. But since nothing can be radically changed, since the timeline is parallel to the causal loop, in any case it seems superfluous to add a time flywheel in any capacity.

Hogwarts Legacy will be released in the holidays of 2022 for PC, PS4, PS5, Switch, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here